The United Nations Office at Geneva
Multimedia Newsroom
Virus hunters continue search for animal link to COVID-19 infections in people
The key work of tracing the animal transmission source of the COVID-19 coronavirus infection in humans is ongoing and must be carried out to prevent future health emergencies, a top UN health agency scientist said on Friday, after the World Health Organization (WHO) confirmed more than 3.5 million cases of infection and 250,000 deaths globally.
Since the respiratory disease emerged in central China in late December, health officials have raced to locate where and how the virus was first transmitted from its animal host to humans.
It is believed that a now-closed Wuhan city wholesale market “played a role” in the outbreak, said Dr Peter Embarek, Food Safety and Zoonosis Expert at WHO, but it is not clear if it was the source.
“All these preliminary studies and interviews and collection of data and so on will help pinpoint both in time and in geographic terms where to look for the source; and it could be again, in this case, it could be again around the markets in Wuhan, but it could also be outside or further out, and therefore, there is no point jumping and starting to testing animals all over the place before having done this groundwork.”
In a videoconference with journalists, Dr Embarek highlighted the fact that many people showed few or no symptoms of infection with COVID-19, likely contributing to the outbreak’s rapid spread.
“We’ve learned a lot about the disease and we know that the vast majority of cases have no or mild symptoms, so it would not be surprising if at that time there were a lot of mild cases that were undetected because we didn’t even know they were mild cases at that time. And that could explain how some of the people who had no link with the market could have been infected.”
In previous coronavirus outbreaks, such as the MERS episode in 2012, finding the missing animal-human link has been far from easy, even though “everybody was looking for the source”, Dr Embarek explained.
In the end, it took months of epidemiological detective work and a slice of “luck” before the transmission link to camels was found, after health officials in Qatar reported two suspect cases linked to a farm, which were followed to confirm the link to the dromedaries.
“It’s not too late, and as I said for the MERS virus, it took about a year before we found the source,” Dr Embarek said. “So it’s never too late but it’s important that we try to find the source and understand what happened at the start of the event to avoid a repeat of this event and to avoid another spillover event in coming years with other different viruses.”
He added: “What would be of great help is if we could get hold of the virus before it adapted to humans, before the version we have now, because then we would better understand how it adapted to humans, how it evolved and what are the changes in the make-up of the virus that most likely did this adaptation. Because now we can see different structures of the virus, we can see mutations sometimes, but we don’t really understand which mutation is critical and which one is less critical; because they are mutating all the time and in 99 per cent of the case this mutation means nothing and we have to understand the critical ones.”
Echoing calls for stronger health controls on wet markets - a common feature of daily life throughout Asia - Dr Embarek noted that the “vast majority can be fixed, can be better organized, because it’s often a question of waste management”.
He added: “It’s a question of people movement and goods movement, it’s a question of separating live animals from animal products and from products that are fresh and cooked products, it’s a question of separating fresh fruits and vegetables from meat products or from live animals. It’s a question of separating the public from the live animals and the people vending and slaughtering these animals; so it’s more about management than regulations and inspections and cleaning and disinfections.”
Concerning the transmissibility of infection to various animals that regularly come into contact with humans, the WHO official noted that “cats and (these) felines are susceptible to the virus; studies with cats have also shown that cats can also transmit the disease to other cats, so this is a group of animals that is interesting to look at, because they are susceptible to the virus. Ferrets have also been shown to be susceptible to the virus, dogs to some extent, but not as efficiently and other species, like domestic species, like pigs, like poultry, chicken and turkey and the like do not seem to be susceptible to the disease, which is good news because we are producing and raising these animals on a very large scale.”
He also said that the new coronavirus could not be transmitted by mosquitos and parasites.
“There has been discussion about mosquitos and whether other animals could transmit the virus and that’s not the case,” Dr Embarek said. “These viruses have very specific affinities to certain animal species and again to their ability to attach and infect specific cells of different species. They cannot at all invade and infect particular animal species so it’s not like can invade whatever they touch or move into.”
Asked about the level of WHO collaboration with Chinese health authorities into tackling COVID-19, he responded that “China has most probably and most likely all the expertise needed to do the investigations; they have a lot of very qualified researchers to do that.”
At the same time, he noted that it was “often useful sometimes to have discussions and to have collaborations with groups and with researchers and with people from all over the world who have had - gone through - similar events and similar studies and have things to share, have experience to share and that has always enriched and improved the speed and quality and likelihood of success of these very complex studies.”
EDITED STORY SHOTLIST
- SOUNDBITE (EN) - Dr Peter Embarek, Food Safety and Zoonosis Expert, WHO: “All these preliminary studies and interviews and collection of data and so on will help pinpoint both in time and in geographic terms where to look for the source; and it could be again, in this case, it could be again around the markets in Wuhan, but it could also be outside or further out, and therefore, there is no point jumping and starting to testing animals all over the place before having done this groundwork.”
- SOUNDBITE (EN) - Dr Peter Embarek, Food Safety and Zoonosis Expert, WHO: “We’ve learned a lot about the disease and we know that the vast majority of cases have no or mild symptoms so it would not be surprising if at that time there were a lot of mild cases that were undetected because we didn’t even know they were mild cases at that time. And that could explain how some of the people who had no link with the market could have been infected…”
- SOUNDBITE (EN) - Dr Peter Embarek, Food Safety and Zoonosis Expert, WHO: “What would be of great help is if we could get hold of the virus before it adapted to humans, before the version we have now, because then we would better understand how it adapted to humans, how it evolved and what are the changes in the make-up of the virus that most likely did this adaptation. Because now we can see different structures of the virus, we can see mutations sometimes, but we don’t really understand which mutation is critical and which one is less critical; because they are mutating all the time and in 99 per cent of the case this mutation means nothing and we have to understand the critical ones.”.”
- SOUNDBITE (EN) - Dr Peter Embarek, Food Safety and Zoonosis Expert, WHO: “It’s not too late, and as I said for the MERS virus, it took about a year before we found the source. So it’s never too late but it’s important that we try to find the source and understand what happened at the start of the event to avoid a repeat of this event and to avoid another spillover event in coming years with other different viruses.”
- SOUNDBITE (EN) - Dr Peter Embarek, Food Safety and Zoonosis Expert, WHO: “But the vast majority can be fixed, can be better organized, because it’s often a question of waste management, it’s a question of people movement and goods movement, it’s a question of separating live animals from animal products and from products that are fresh and cooked products, it’s a question of separating fresh fruits and vegetables from meat products or from live animals. It’s a question of separating the public from the live animals and the people vending and slaughtering these animals; so it’s more about management than regulations and inspections and cleaning and disinfections.”
- SOUNDBITE (EN) - Dr Peter Embarek, Food Safety and Zoonosis Expert, WHO: “Cats and these felines are susceptible to the virus; studies with cats have also shown that cats can also transmit the disease to other cats, so this is a group of animals that is interesting to look at, because they are susceptible to the virus. Ferrets have also been shown to be susceptible to the virus, dogs to some extent, but not as efficiently and other species, like domestic species, like pigs, like poultry, chicken and turkey and the like do not seem to be susceptible to the disease, which is good news because we are producing and raising these animals on a very large scale.”
- SOUNDBITE (EN) - Dr Peter K. Ben Embarek, Food Safety and Zoonosis Expert, WHO: “There has been discussion about mosquitos and whether other animals could transmit the virus and that’s not the case. These viruses have very specific affinities to certain animal species and again to their ability to attach and infect specific cells of different species. They cannot at all invade and infect particular animal species so it’s not like can invade whatever they touch or move into.”
- SOUNDBITE (EN) - Dr Peter Embarek, Food Safety and Zoonosis Expert, WHO: “China has most probably and most likely all the expertise needed to do the investigations; they have a lot of very qualified researchers to do that, but as I said, it is often useful sometimes to have discussions and collaborations with groups and with researchers and with people from all over the world who have had, gone through similar events and similar studies and have things to share, have experience to share and that has always enriched and improve the speed and quality and likelihood of success of these very complex studies.”
Similar Stories
1
1
1
Press Conferences | OHCHR
"Counter-terrorism abuses challenging the international order" (definition of terrorism, use of force under the pretext of counter-terrorism, narco-terrorism)
2
1
2
Press Conferences , Edited News | HRC
Russia’s deportations of Ukrainian children amount to crimes against humanity: independent UN rights probe
Scores of Ukrainian children are still missing after being deported far and wide across Russia and occupied territories while their families continue to search for them, human rights investigators said on Thursday.
2
1
2
Edited News , Press Conferences | OCHA
The UN’s emergency relief chief on Wednesday condemned the “$1 billion-a-day” cost of the war roiling the Middle East, at a time of severe cuts to the global body’s humanitarian work in emergencies and “soaring” needs.
1
1
1
Press Conferences | HRC
Press conference with the Group of Human Rights Experts on Nicaragua following the release of their report to the 61st session of the Human Rights Council.
1
1
1
Edited News | OHCHR , WHO , UNHCR , UNICEF , WFP
Middle East war: UN warns of ‘toxic rain’ danger from oil depot strikes as mass displacement, aid supply shocks spread
Toxic “black rain” linked to strikes on oil depots, mass displacement and continuing disruption to humanitarian supply chains are upending lives across the Middle East and beyond after 10 days of war in the region, UN humanitarians said on Tuesday.
1
1
1
Press Conferences | UNRISD , UNECE , UNHCR , WHO , OHCHR , UNDP , WFP
Rolando Gómez, Chief of the Press and External Relations at the United Nations Information Service in Geneva, chaired a hybrid press briefing, which was attended by the spokespersons and representatives of the United Nations Refugee Agency, the World Health Organization, the United Nations Children’s Fund, the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, the World Food Programme, the United Nations Research Institute for Social Development, the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe, and the United Nations Development Programme.
1
1
1
Press Conferences | IPU
IPU report discusses women in parliament, featuring speakers Martin Chungong and Mariana Mutzenberg.
1
1
1
Edited News | OHCHR , UNOG
UN Human Rights Spokesperson Ravina Shamdasani on Friday made the following remarks on Israel’s military ground incursions and displacement orders in Lebanon.
1
1
1
Edited News | OHCHR , IOM , WHO
The escalating war in the Middle East has heightened growing concerns about further civilian suffering and displacement in the region and far beyond, UN agencies said on Friday.
1
1
1
Press Conferences | IOM , OHCHR , UNHCR , WHO
Alessandra Vellucci, Director of the United Nations Information Service in Geneva, chaired a hybrid press briefing, which was attended by the spokespersons and representatives of the United Nations Refugee Agency, the World Health Organization, the International Organization for Migration, and the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights.
2
1
2
Press Conferences , Edited News | OHCHR
UN Human Rights chief Volker Türk made the following remarks at a press stake out on the current situation in the Middle East.
“The crisis sparked in the Middle East one week ago following US and Israeli attacks on Iran, and Iran’s counterattacks, has been spreading like wildfire. It is causing significant damage in Iran, Israel and at least a dozen other countries, mostly in the Gulf, with risks of major economic and environmental ramifications across the world,” he said.
1
1
1
Press Conferences | HRC
Housing crisis needs urgent action on affordability and climate