Crimes against journalists Diego Luna and RSF 20 November 2024
/
4:35
/
MP4
/
536.3 MB
Download

Edited News | UNOG

Crimes against journalists Diego Luna and RSF - 20NOV2024 1

“State of Silence”: Diego Luna brings the fight to protect the press to the UN in Geneva

Mexican actor, producer and director Diego Luna has brought his fight to protect journalists all the way to the United Nations, in Geneva.

Together with documentary director Santiago Masa, he is putting a spotlight on the silencing of investigative journalism in his country, and on the incredibly high price that many journalist have to pay in pursuit of truth.

Mr. Luna is the executive producer of “State of Silence”, a documentary on the challenges of press freedom in Mexico. The film, which Santiago Maza directed, portrays four courageous Mexican journalists who have become targets in retaliation for their reporting on organized crime and systemic corruption. Many reporters have been forced into hiding or into exile, limiting the public’s access to critical information.

“There are areas that have been silenced in our country”, the star of the “Narcos: Mexico” series told UN News, as he explained how violence, impunity, threats against journalists have been growing to the point of creating “zones of silence, zones where one doesn’t find out what is happening because there is no one to report stories”.

Since 2017, there have been 69 recorded murders and 32 documented cases of disappearances of journalists in Mexico, a staggering number for a country that is not at war, according to the United Nations Human Rights office (OHCHR). The UN’s human rights arm leads the International Day to End Impunity for Crimes Against Journalists, and partnered with the “State of Silence” production team to screen the documentary at a theatrical premiere in the Swiss city of Geneva.

High level of Impunity

“Violence exists because nothing happens, because it can be done”, alerted Diego Luna. “It is just a sample of what we live in the country, a country with a very high level of impunity”, he insisted. “Also, journalism experiences a head-on confrontation and a disqualification from the different powers, not only the political power and but also the economic forces. There is a constant disqualification and then an indifference as well. We have normalized violence, we have normalized injustice, we have normalized inequality in our country,” deplored the renowned actor.

Mexico ranks 121st in the World Press Freedom Index of Reporters Without Borders (RSF) and 165th in terms of safety. This reality reflects the decline of media freedom the OHCHR has observed in all regions of the globe in recent years. Between 2006 and 2024, over 1,700 journalists have been killed around the world in possible connection with their work, and around 85 percent of the cases did not make it to court, according to a report of the UN Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) that is mandated with keeping track of and promoting journalists’ safety worldwide. It also reveals that murders of journalists rose 38 per cent between 2022 and 2023.

“It’s too easy to get away with crime”, emphasized Thibaut Bruttin, Director General of Reporters Without Borders who took part in the panel debate after the screening. “If you are an armed group, a mafia group, in many countries around the world, there is very little chance statistically that you will be held accountable. So that involves stimulating the prosecutors and teams who must investigate these cases”, he added.

Beside the impunity and lack of protection, journalists in many countries also face the criminalization of their activities. Diego Luna denounced the indifference and solitude that reporters often endure while carrying out their investigations, and the fatalism in public expression about the work of media.

For the movie star, the support of international organizations like the United Nations is fundamental for these issues to gain a wider resonance, to connect the reality of the journalists in Mexico with those of others in different parts of the world.

Echoing those concerns, Reporters Without Borders warned against the mix of information between pure propaganda, advertising, rumor, opinion and journalism that “truly risks perishing in this ecosystem which is also economically not favorable,” and the need to foster a social and political environment that actively defends the access to reliable information, the role of the media and recognize its liability.

“When you have professional skills and a liability regime associated with your publication, you should benefit from advantages from the technological platforms, from the public with a label, from advertisers, from public authorities. And it is this virtuous circle of journalism that we must build together», explained Mr. Bruttin.

State of Silence premiered this year at the Tribeca International Film Festival in the United States and the Guadalajara International Film Festival in Mexico. It won Best Feature Film at the Santiago International Film Festival in Chile.

-ends-

Story: “Crimes against journalists – Diego Luna and RSF” – 14 November 2024

Speakers:

  • Diego Luna, actor, director and producer
  • Thibaut Bruttin, Director General of Reporters Without Borders (RSF

TRT: 04’36”
SOURCE: UNTV CH
LANGUAGE: ENGLISH / NATS
ASPECT RATIO: 16:9
DATELINE shote on: 14 November 2024 - GENEVA, SWITZERLAND
One to one interviews in TV Studio Geneva


SHOTLIST

  1. Diego Luna and Director Santiago Maza walking in front of the United Nations building in Geneva towards the press conference room.

  2. Soundbite (Spanish) Diego Luna, actor, director and producer: “’Estado de silencio’ es el título de un documental que habla sobre ejercer el periodismo hoy en México, como hay zonas que han sido silenciadas en nuestro país. Hoy la violencia, la impunidad, las amenazas contra el periodismo han ido creciendo al punto de crear zonas de silencio, zonas donde no nos enteramos de qué es lo que pasa, donde no hay nadie contándonos esas historias.”
    English translation: “'State of silence' is the title of a documentary that talks about practicing journalism today in Mexico, how there are areas that have been silenced in our country. Today violence, impunity, threats against journalism have been growing to the point of creating zones of silence, zones where we do not find out what is happening, where there is no one to tell us stories.”

  3. Video clip: excerpt of the trailer presenting the four Mexican journalists portrayed.

  4. Soundbite (Spanish) Diego Luna, actor, director and producer: “Esta violencia existe porque no pasa nada, porque se puede. Es solo el botón de muestra de lo que se vive en el país, un país con un altísimo nivel de impunidad.”
    English translation: “This violence exists because nothing happens, because it can be done. It is just a sample of what we live in the country, a country with a very high level of impunity.”

  1. Cutaway: wide shot of the press conference room in Geneva.

  2. Soundbite (Spanish) Diego Luna, actor, director and producer: “Hoy, el periodismo vive una confrontación frontal y una descalificación de los distintos poderes, no solo el poder político sino el económico también. Hay una descalificación constante y luego una indiferencia también: hemos normalizado la violencia, hemos normalizado la injusticia, hemos normalizado la desigualdad en nuestro país.”
    English translation: “Today, journalism is facing a head-on confrontation and a disqualification from the different powers, not only from the political power but the economic forces as well. There is a constant disqualification and then indifference as well: we have normalized violence, we have normalized injustice, we have normalized inequality in our country.”
  1. Medium shot of Thibaut Bruttin being interviewed in the press conference room.

  2. Soundbite (French) Thibaut Bruttin, Director General of Reporters Without Borders (RSF): « Aujourd'hui, c'est trop facile de s'en tirer. Si vous êtes un groupe armé, un groupe mafieux, dans beaucoup de pays du monde, il y a très peu de chances statistiquement, que vous ayez à rendre des comptes tôt ou tard. Donc ça, ça passe par la stimulation des procureurs et des équipes qui doivent enquêter sur ces affaires-là. »
    English translation: “Today, it’s too easy to get away with it. If you are an armed group, a mafia group, in many countries around the world, there is very little chance statistically that you will be held accountable. So, that involves stimulating the prosecutors and the teams who must investigate these cases. »

  3. Video clip: excerpt of the trailer.

  4. Soundbite (Spanish) Diego Luna, actor, director and producer: “Nosotros podemos ayudar no solo a que el cine termine conectándoles con el público, sino además con quienes hacen y ejercen el periodismo en otros países, en otros territorios. Y para eso es importante el trabajo que se puede hacer, por ejemplo, desde aquí, desde la ONU, en crear, entender estas redes, en crear lazos entre quienes hoy están viviendo una realidad similar en otros países.”
    English translation: “We can help not only so that cinema ends up connecting them (the journalists) with the public, but also with those who make and practice journalism in other countries, in other territories. And for that, the work that can be done from here, from the UN, is important in creating and understanding these networks, in creating ties between those who today are living a similar reality in other countries.”

  5. Wide travelling shot on the public at Cinérama Empire theater in Geneva.
  1. Medium shot of Diego Luna taking selfies with fans following the screening.

  2. Soundbite (French) Thibaut Bruttin, Director General of Reporters Without Borders (RSF) : «On est dans un capharnaüm aujourd'hui où vous avez un mélange entre des informations qui sont de la pure propagande, de la publicité, de la rumeur, du commentaire et au milieu de tout ça se trouve le pauvre journalisme. Et le journalisme risque véritablement de périr dans cet écosystème qui lui est, en plus, économiquement défavorable. »
    English translation: “We are in a mess today where you have a mixture between information which is pure propaganda, advertising, rumor, opinion and in the middle of all that is journalism. And journalism truly risks perishing in this ecosystem which is also economically unfavorable to it. »

  3. Wide shot of theater and screen showing “State of Silence”.

  4. Medium shot of the panel discussion at Cinérama Empire theater with Thibaut Bruttin talking.
    (Members of the panel from left to right are: Gunilla von Hall, Swedish journalist; Thibaut Bruttin RSF; Diego Luna and Volker Türk, High Commissioner for Human Rights).

  5. Soundbite (French) Thibaut Bruttin, Director General of Reporters Without Borders (RSF) : «Quand vous avez des compétences professionnelles, quand vous avez un régime de responsabilité qui est associé à votre publication, vous devriez bénéficier d’avantages auprès des plateformes technologiques, auprès du public avec un label, auprès des annonceurs, auprès des pouvoirs publics. Et c'est ce cercle vertueux du journalisme qu'il faut qu'on construise ensemble. »
    English translation: “When you have professional skills, when you have a liability regime associated with your publication, you should benefit from advantages from the technological platforms, from the public with a label, from advertisers, from public authorities. And it is this virtuous circle of journalism that we must build together. »

Clean version of the trailer and film excerpts attached.
Trailer and film excerpts with English subtitles available here


Audio Files 3
Download Crimes against journalists Diego Luna and RSF - 20NOV2024 1 (Edited Story)
Download
Download Trailer clean version - Estado de silencio (1080p) (Edited Story)
Download
Download Crimes against journalists Diego Luna and RSF 20 November 2024 (Edited Story)
Download

Similar Stories

Gaza humanitarian update - OCHA, UNRWA

1

1

1

Edited News | OCHA , UNRWA

Gaza humanitarian update - OCHA, UNRWA ENG FRA

As a controversial United States and Israel-backed aid distribution plan gets underway in Gaza, the UN called on Tuesday for an “immediate surge” of its own pre-positioned supplies to help prevent starvation.

Uganda UN Human Rights Spokesperson Ravina Shamdasani  urges president to reject bill allowing trials of civilians in military courts

1

1

1

Edited News | OHCHR

Uganda UN Human Rights Spokesperson Ravina Shamdasani urges president to reject bill allowing trials of civilians in military courts ENG FRA

UN Human Rights Office Spokesperson Ravina Shamdasani today urged Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni to reject a bill that was recently endorsed by parliament allowing trials of civilians in military courts. The Uganda People’s Defence Forces Amendment Bill 2025, which was passed on 20 May and now awaits presidential signature to become law, among others broadens the jurisdiction of military courts, authorising them to try a wide range of offences against civilians.

UN Human Rights Office spokesperson Seif Magango: South Sudan: UN human rights chief decries escalating hostilities, arbitrary arrests and hate speech

1

1

1

Edited News | OHCHR

UN Human Rights Office spokesperson Seif Magango: South Sudan: UN human rights chief decries escalating hostilities, arbitrary arrests and hate speech ENG FRA

UN Human Rights Office spokesperson Seif Magango today warned of a further deterioration in the human rights situation in South Sudan at the bi-weekly briefing in Geneva.

Syria humanitarian update OCHA - WHO 23 May 2025

1

1

1

Edited News | OCHA , WHO

Syria humanitarian update OCHA - WHO 23 May 2025 ENG FRA

Syria: ‘Staggering’ needs amid insecurity, health care crisis  - UN humanitarians

Millions of people in Syria continue to face mortal danger from unexploded munitions, disease and malnutrition and urgent support is required, UN humanitarians said on Friday.

Gaza health update - UNRWA - OCHA - WHO

1

1

1

Edited News | UNRWA , OCHA , WHO

Gaza health update - UNRWA - OCHA - WHO ENG FRA

UN life-saving aid allowed to trickle into Gaza as civilian needs mount

Amid calls for more humanitarian trucks to enter the food and medicine-deprived Palestinian enclave of Gaza, UN humanitarians have received permission from Israel for “around 100” more aid trucks to cross into the Strip after only five were let in yesterday,  But the scale of relief efforts allowed remains entirely insufficient to meet the urgent needs of people there, humanitarian workers say.

Press vests becoming a target - war reporter Christina Assi

1

1

1

Edited News

Press vests becoming a target - war reporter Christina Assi ENG FRA

A war reporter from Lebanon who lost a limb in the line of duty is calling for an end to impunity for attacks against journalists.

ITU 160th Anniversary - 17 May 2025

1

1

1

Edited News | ITU

ITU 160th Anniversary - 17 May 2025 ENG FRA

The International Telecommunication Union (ITU) commemorated 160 years dedicated to connecting the world on Saturday, 17 May in Geneva, Switzerland, during the annual World Telecommunication and Information Society Day.

Gaza humanitarian update – WHO, OCHA 16 May 2025

1

1

1

Edited News | WHO , OCHA

Gaza humanitarian update – WHO, OCHA 16 May 2025 ENG FRA

Gazans ‘in terror’ after another night of deadly strikes and siege

Amid reports that Israeli strikes across Gaza into Friday killed at least 64 people, aid teams once again pushed back strongly at allegations that aid is being diverted to Hamas and pleaded for the blockade to end.

UN Human Rights raises human rights concerns about deportations from the United States of America

1

1

1

Edited News | OHCHR , UNOG

UN Human Rights raises human rights concerns about deportations from the United States of America ENG FRA

Deportations over recent months of large numbers of non-nationals from the United States of America, especially to countries other than those of their origin, raise a number of human rights concerns, the UN Human Rights Chief Volker Türk warned on Tuesday.   

Gaza health update - WHO

1

1

1

Edited News | WHO

Gaza health update - WHO ENG FRA

Gaza: Over 50 child malnutrition deaths amid aid blockade; entire generation will be ‘permanently affected’ - WHO

In the aid desert of Gaza, malnourished children are dying while survivors can expect a lifetime of dire health problems, the UN World Health Organization (WHO) said on Tuesday.

Gaza aid update - UNICEF, UNRWA, WHO 09 May 2025

1

1

1

Edited News | WHO , UNICEF , UNRWA

Gaza aid update - UNICEF, UNRWA, WHO 09 May 2025 ENG FRA

Israel’s aid plan will force Gaza families to choose ‘between displacement and death’ – UN humanitarians

Israel’s plan to take control of relief assistance in Gaza risks increasing the suffering of families already exhausted by 18 months of war by putting their lives in danger and inciting more displacement, using aid as “bait”, UN humanitarians said on Friday.

Gaza humanitarian blockade  OCHA - WHO

1

1

1

Edited News | OCHA , WHO

Gaza humanitarian blockade OCHA - WHO ENG FRA

UN Humanitarians reject Israeli plan to take over aid delivery

The reported Israeli proposal to deliver humanitarian supplies through hubs controlled by the military would be a breach of the core principles of neutral, impartial and independent aid delivery, the UN aid coordination office, OCHA, said on Tuesday.