The United Nations Office at Geneva
Multimedia Newsroom
Edited News , Press Conferences | UNITED NATIONS
Commission of Inquiry Occupied Palestinian Territories and Israel 14 June 2022
Commission of Inquiry on Occupied Palestinian Territory and Israel asks for greater access to address allegations of bias
Ending the continued Israeli occupation of Palestinian territory is essential to stopping the conflict and halting the persistent cycle of violence said the independent experts charged by the Human Rights Council with investigating the root causes of conflict, who today made a plea for better access to the people and locations most affected by the conflict.
“The root cause is clearly the occupation, and the occupation must end”, said the Commission’s chair, Ms. Navi Pillay, at a news conference in Geneva.
The former UN High Commissioner for Human Rights had presented the report to the Human Rights Council yesterday. “We call this a ‘perpetual occupation’ and we say that's the core underlying root cause of ongoing violence displayed in terms of the force displacement, the threats of forced displacements, demolitions, settlement construction and expansions, settler violence and the blockade of Gaza,” Ms. Pillay said.
“As we all know, this has endured for decades, and there's a sense of despair and hopelessness within the Palestinian population, as well as in Israel and the Diaspora,”
she added.
The report by the three-member commission has generated a lot of media interest but has also has been rejected by many supporters of Israel, who have complained of bias by the Commission.
“We are listening to all stakeholders of whatever political point of view”, said Ms. Pillay, in response to these allegations of bias.
The three-member panel said it regretted Israel’s refusal to cooperate with the Commission, and maintained that the allegations of bias could be addressed if only they were given access to Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territory in order to interview people and gather information.
“We are disappointed that Israel has not permitted us to visit Israel”, said Ms. Pillay. “To see for ourselves, to talk to victims, particularly of the Hamas rocket attacks, it's very important that we have a balanced report reflecting the situation of all victims. I constantly hear murmuring that we are very biased, and we only represent the one side, that’s the anti-Israel side. So, I cannot understand why they wouldn't let us in. and interview appropriate witnesses.”
The Commission released its 18-page report after conducting an assessment of recommendations made by previous Commissions of Inquiry and Fact-Finding-Missions, as well as other United Nations mechanisms and its own hearing.
According to Miloon Kothari, member of the Commission of Inquiry, “we are not looking only at individual events of human rights violations, but we are trying to establish patterns, patterns that are historical patterns that are very inimical to the occupation that are leading to these constant cycles of violence and conflict.”
The Commission undertook two missions to Geneva and one to Jordan, and held consultations with various stakeholders, including Israeli and Palestinian civil society organizations.
“We are very concerned about this issue of double standards”, said Mr. Kothari. “And now it has sharply come out in the context of the crisis in Ukraine. And we are very clear that these are double standards, and the international community is rightly appalled in the face of aggression and occupation and has correctly moved to act swiftly and collectively and forcefully to ensure compliance with international law”, he said. “But in the case of Israel and Palestine”, so Mr. Kothari, “there has been inaction for decades and it continues.”
The former South African jurist Navi Pillay stressed the importance of the future work of the Commission to look also for solutions. “We want everyone to take this Commission seriously because it’s the first time it can look into political questions which you can't do under the Human Rights Council regular mandates. And we are all very keen to find solutions. We're not here just to say, how bad things are. People on the ground know it's bad,” she said.
“There is a possibility in the next couple of years for the first time in a generation of new people and new ideas and new openings,” said Commission member Chris Sidoti, on a more hopeful note. “I'm not naive. I'm not utopian. I don't say that this window is wide open. But I say that it's opened a little bit. And that places a grave responsibility on the international system and individual states to take advantage of what may be a once-in-a-generation opportunity to pressure for change, push for change, reopen possibilities that have been locked.”
-ends-
- Exterior medium shot, Palais des Nations flag alley, a sunny day.
- Wide shot, journalists, podium and moderator in press briefing room, Palais des Nations.
- SOUNDBITE (English) — Navi Pillay, Chair of the Commission of Inquiry: “The root cause is clearly the occupation, and the occupation must end.”
- Medium wide shot, podium speakers seated to the right of the shot, journalists to the left.
- SOUNDBITE (English) — Navi Pillay, Chair of the Commission of Inquiry: “So we call this a perpetual occupation, and we say that's the core underlying root cause of ongoing violence displayed in terms of the force displacement, the threats of forced displacements, demolitions, settlement construction and expansions, settler violence and the blockade of Gaza. And as we all know, this has endured for decades, and there's a sense of despair and hopelessness within the Palestinian population, as well as in Israel and the Diaspora.”
- Medium shot, side shot of the podium speakers seated in the foreground, TV screen showing the speaker to rear.
- SOUNDBITE (English) — Navi Pillay, Chair of the Commission of Inquiry: “We are listening to all stakeholders of whatever political point of view and so on.”
- Medium shot, two participants taking notes in foreground, TV screen showing the speaker to rear.
- SOUNDBITE (English) — Navi Pillay, Chair of the Commission of Inquiry: “We are disappointed that Israel has not permitted us to visit Israel. To see for ourselves, to talk to victims, particularly of the Hamas rocket attacks, it's very important that we have a balanced report reflecting the situation of all victims. I constantly hear murmuring that we are very biased, and we only represent the one side, that’s the anti-Israel side. So, I cannot understand why they wouldn't let us in and interview appropriate witnesses.”
- Medium shot, side shot of the podium speakers, TV screen to rear.
- SOUNDBITE (English) — Miloon Kothari, Member of Commission of Inquiry: “We are not looking only at individual events of human rights violations, but we are trying to establish patterns, patterns that are historical patterns that are very inimical to the occupation that are leading to these constant cycles of violence and conflict.”
- Medium shot, participants sitting and following the press conference.
- SOUNDBITE (English) — Miloon Kothari, Member of Commission of Inquiry: “We are very concerned about this issue of double standards. And now it has sharply come out in the context of the crisis in Ukraine. And we are very clear that these are double standards, and the international community is rightly appalled in the face of aggression and occupation and has correctly moved to act swiftly and collectively and forcefully to ensure compliance with international law. But in the case of Israel and Palestine, there has been inaction for decades and it continues.”
- Medium wide shot, cameraperson taking photos besides cameras in foreground, participants listening to far.
- SOUNDBITE (English) — Navi Pillay, Chair of the Commission of Inquiry: “We want everyone to take this Commission seriously because it’s the first time it can look into political questions which you can't do under the Human Rights Council regular mandates. And we are all very keen to find solutions. We're not here just to say, how bad things are. People on the ground know it's bad.”
- Medium shot, journalists seated and listening to the speaker carefully.
- SOUNDBITE (English) — Chris Sidoti, Member of Commission of Inquiry: “There is a possibility in the next couple of years for the first time in a generation of new people and new ideas and new openings. I'm not naive. I'm not utopian. I don't say that this window is wide open. But I say that it's opened a little bit. And that places a grave responsibility on the international system and individual states to take advantage of what may be a once-in-a-generation opportunity to pressure for change, push for change, reopen possibilities that have been locked.”
- Wide shot, ground shot in the press conference room, podium speakers seated with TV screen on their left and right side.
Similar Stories
1
1
1
Edited News | OHCHR
Ravina Shamdasani, UN Human Rights spokesperson, made the following comments at the bi-weekly press briefing of the United Nations on the United States’ intervention in Venezuela.
1
1
1
Edited News | OCHA , OHCHR
Venezuela: US military intervention ‘far from victory for human rights’, makes world less safe – UN rights office
The UN rights office (OHCHR) on Tuesday expressed concern over the situation in Venezuela following the United States military operation and seizure of President Nicolás Maduro over the weekend, insisting that the move runs counter to international law and damages global security.
1
1
1
Press Conferences | OCHA , OHCHR , UNHCR
Alessandra Vellucci, Director of the United Nations Information Service in Geneva, chaired a hybrid press briefing, which was attended by spokespersons and representatives of the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs and the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.
1
1
1
Press Conferences | OCHA
U.S. Mission in Geneva hosts MOU signing and funding event with key humanitarian speakers.
1
1
1
Press Conferences | UNHCR , IOM , FAO , WHO , OCHA , UNICEF
Alessandra Vellucci, Director of the United Nations Information Service in Geneva, chaired a hybrid press briefing, which was attended by the representatives and spokespersons of the United Nations Refugee Agency, the International Organization for Migration, the Food and Agriculture Organization, the World Health Organization, the United Nations Children's Fund and the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs.
1
1
1
Edited News | IOM
As fighting spreads across Sudan in a dangerous new escalation, "people are scared, people are fleeing their homes," the UN migration agency, IOM, said on Friday, noting that more than 50,000 people have fled attacks and violence since late October in Kordofan region alone.
1
1
1
Edited News | OHCHR , UNOG
Volker Türk the UN Human Rights High Commissioner made the following remarks during and Oral update tothe Human Rights Council intersessional meeting on Venezuela.
1
1
1
Edited News | WHO
New flu variant is surging, but vaccination still our best bet - WHO
Amid an early start to the Northern Hemisphere influenza season a new variant of the virus is rapidly gaining ground - but vaccination remains the “most effective defence”, the UN health agency said on Tuesday.
1
1
1
Press Conferences | WFP , WHO
Alessandra Vellucci, Director of the United Nations Information Service (UNIS) in Geneva, chaired the hybrid briefing, which was attended by spokespersons and representatives from the United Nations Office at Geneva, the World Food Programme, and the World Health Organization.
1
1
1
Press Conferences | UNOG
Tatiana Valovaya, Director-General of the UN Office at Geneva, gave a year-end briefing to the Geneva press corps.
1
1
1
Press Conferences | WFP , UNHCR , WHO , IOM , UNFPA
Alessandra Vellucci, Director of the United Nations Information Service in Geneva, chaired a hybrid press briefing, which was attended by the representatives and spokespersons of the United Nations Refugee Agency, the World Food Programme, the World Health Organization, the International Organization for Migration, and the United Nations Population Fund.